James Caan

Salvatore Palmeri

Janet Wright

Angie - Patty's Mother

Gabriel Hogan

Robert Wilford

Heather Hanson

June

Tony Nappo

Carmine

Alessandro Costantini

Joey Montanari

Kyle Harrington

Nino

Gina Wilkinson

Mary Russo

Michael A. Miranda

Jimmy

Alex Karzis

Bones

Alvaro D'Antonio

Vito

Jason Blicker

Dante Montanari

Zak Longo

Mouse Russo

Stefano DiMatteo

Restaurant Owner (Stefano Colacitti)

Sandra Crljenica

Angie - 15 years

Megan Hetting

Patty 8 years

Louca Tassone

Young Joey

Anthony Moniz Lancione

Young Nino

Paula Rivera

Nun

Karen LeBlanc

M.C.

Daniel Dyer

Singer 1

Tulsi Balram

Singer 2

Louis Di Bianco

Capo 1

Domenico Fiore

Capo 2

Rothaford Gray

US Border

Phillip Jarrett

Sergeant

Pete Zedlacher

First Agent

John Watson

Second Agent

David W. Collins

Toronto Cop

Claudio Masciulli

Man at Funeral

Anna Starnino

Woman at Funeral

Johnny Gardhouse

Auto Parts Guy

Hume Baugh

Cop at Confirmation

Mary Pitt

Fur Store Clerk

Devon Graye

Nino Narrator (voice)

Sima Fisher

Waitress (uncredited)

Anthony Melchiorri

Uncle Tito (uncredited)