Film Snail

Phantom of the Opera
Phantom of the Opera

6.2

Phantom of the Opera

NR·1943·89m

Summary

Following a tragic accident that leaves him disfigured, crazed composer Erique Claudin transformed into a masked phantom who schemes to make beautiful young soprano Christine Dubois the star of the opera and wreak revenge on those who stole his music.

Cast

Nelson Eddy

Nelson Eddy

Anatole Garron

Susanna Foster

Susanna Foster

Christine Dubois

Claude Rains

Claude Rains

Erique Claudin

Edgar Barrier

Edgar Barrier

Raoul D'Aubert

Leo Carrillo

Leo Carrillo

Signor Ferretti

Jane Farrar

Jane Farrar

Biancarolli

J. Edward Bromberg

J. Edward Bromberg

Amiot

Fritz Feld

Fritz Feld

Lecours

Frank Puglia

Frank Puglia

Villeneuve

Steven Geray

Steven Geray

Vereheres

Barbara Everest

Barbara Everest

The Aunt

Hume Cronyn

Hume Cronyn

Gerard

Fritz Leiber

Fritz Leiber

Franz Liszt

Nicki Andre

Madame Lorenzi

Gladys Blake

Gladys Blake

Jeanne

Elvira Curci

Elvira Curci

Biancarolli's Maid

Hans Herbert

Marcel

Kate Drain Lawson

Kate Drain Lawson

Landlady

Miles Mander

Miles Mander

Pleyel

Rosina Galli

Rosina Galli

Christine's Maid

Walter O. Stahl

Doctor (as Walter Stahl)

Paul Marion

Paul Marion

Desjardines

Richard Bartell

Reporter (uncredited)

Edward Biby

Operagoer (uncredited)

Eumenio Blanco

Minor Role (uncredited)

Stanley Blystone

Stanley Blystone

Officer (uncredited)

Beatrice Roberts

Beatrice Roberts

Nurse (uncredited)

Belle Mitchell

Belle Mitchell

Feretti's Maid (uncredited)

James Mitchell

James Mitchell

Reporter (uncredited)

Renee Carson

Georgette (uncredited)

Wheaton Chambers

Wheaton Chambers

Reporter (uncredited)

Lane Chandler

Lane Chandler

Officer (uncredited)

Edward Clark

Usher (uncredited)

James Conaty

Operagoer (uncredited)

Paul Cristo

Policeman (uncredited)

Jack Deery

Operagoer (uncredited)

William Desmond

William Desmond

Stagehand (uncredited)

Helen Dickson

Operagoer (uncredited)

Ernest Golm

Office Manager (uncredited)

Bella Lewitzky

Dancer (uncredited)

Hank Mann

Hank Mann

Stagehand (uncredited)

Anthony Marlowe

'Marta' Singer (uncredited)

Alphonse Martell

Alphonse Martell

Policeman (uncredited)

Eric Mayne

Eric Mayne

Reporter (uncredited)

Robert Robinson

Citizen (uncredited)

Victor Romito

Actor in Play (uncredited)

John Roy

Actor in Play (uncredited)

Muni Seroff

Reporter (uncredited)

Johnny Walsh

Office Boy (uncredited)

Tudor Williams

'Marta' Singer (uncredited)

Marek Windheim

Marek Windheim

Renfrit (uncredited)

Crew

Director

Arthur Lubin

Adaptation

Hans Jacoby

Dialogue

Joan Hathaway

Novel

Gaston Leroux

Screenplay

Samuel Hoffenstein

Screenplay

Eric Taylor

Reviews

John Chard

John Chard

January 28, 2019

5

Well it's one of the most beautiful Universal Horror movies out there.

Phantom of the Opera is directed by Arthur Lubin and features a collective of writers adapting from Gaston Leroux's novel. It stars Nelson Eddy, Claude Rains, Edgar Barrier, Susanna Foster, Leo Carrillo and Jane Farrar. Music is by Edward Ward and cinematography by W. Howard Greene.

The Leroux source material has been adapted a number of times. This version sees Universal update their own 1925 silent version that starred Lon Chaney, and give it a Technicolor make over whilst practically making it a musical picture. Even making it a light comedy in parts! It is undeniably a gorgeous picture, both visually and aurally, for the sets and operatic tunes alone this could never be called a dull movie. But we want horror, it's an horrific tale of murder, disfigurement, disloyalty and unbridled passions, we don't want to be watching a Phantom of the Opera movie where at any moment you expect the cast to start singing "ding dong the witch is dead". Cast are mostly fine as regards the tone of the piece, though Rains barely gets his teeth into the role of the Phantom and comes off more like Zorro or the Lone Ranger. While Lubin and his crew give the whole production a professional polish.

But is this horror? No, never, and that's a shame given it's from the torch bearers for classic horror of the 30s and 40s. 5/10

Media

Status:

Released

Original Language:

English

Budget:

$1,500,000.00

Revenue:

$0.00

Keywords

opera
musical
remake
gothic horror
technicolor
literary adaptation
stage musical
phantom of the opera