Doug Walker

Nostalgia Critic / Chester A. Bum / Spider Smith / Ask That Guy With The Glasses / Dominick

Lindsay Ellis

Nostalgia Chick

Lewis Lovhaug

Linkara

Noah Antwiler

The Spoony One / Dr. Insano

Brad Jones

Cinema Snob

Joe Vargas

Angry Joe

Phelan Porteous

Phelous

Benjamin Daniel

Benzaie / Beary

Kaylyn Saucedo

MarzGurl (as Kaylyn Dicksion)

Bennett White

Bennett the Sage

Jason Pullara

LordKat

Mickey Paradis

8-Bit Mickey

Thomas Hanley

Handsome Tom

Mathew Buck

Film Brain

Paul Schuler

Paw

Bhargav Dronamraju

Ma-Ti

Kevin Baugh

Self / Fritz von Baugh

James D. Rolfe

Board James (as James D. Rolfe)

Rob Walker

Narrator / Santa Christ

Nick Landis

Lanipator (as Team Four Star)

Lee Davidge

2D Lee / 3D Lee

Chris Larios

Rollo T

Krissy Diggs

That Chick With The Goggles

Lindsey Z. Briggs

Little Miss Gamer

Sean Fausz

Hope Within Chaos

Nikolas Freeman

Y Ruler of Time

Lawrence Simpson

MasakoX (as Team Four Star)

Mike Jeavons

Mike J.

Brian Heinz

The Last Angry Geek

Larry Bundy Jr.

Guru Larry

Dena Natali

Dena

Sam Goldberg

That Jewish Guy / Guy Lynor

Christine Thompson

The Cat

Patrick Burdun

Patrick Burdun

Scott Frerichs

KaiserNeko (uncredited)

Eli James

The Toll Troll

Curtis Arnott

Takahata101 (uncredited)