Laura Linney

Samantha Prescott

Mark Ruffalo

Terry Prescott

Matthew Broderick

Brian Everett

Jon Tenney

Bob Steegerson

Rory Culkin

Rudy Prescott

Halley Feiffer

Amy

J. Smith-Cameron

Mabel

Josh Lucas

Rudy (Kolinski) Sr.

Gaby Hoffmann

Sheila

Amy Ryan

Rachel Louise Prescott

Adam LeFevre

Sheriff Darryl

Kenneth Lonergan

Ron

Nina Garbiras

Nancy Everett

Kim Parker

Rudy Sr.'s Girlfriend

Michael Countryman

Thomas Gerard Prescott

Whitney Vance

Young Sammy Prescott

Peter Kerwin

Young Terry Prescott

Betsy Aidem

Minister

Lisa Altomare

Waitress

Richard Hummer

Plumber

Allan Gill

Older Cop

Brian Ramage

Young Cop